We use cookies

Moalem Weitemeyer uses cookies, including cookies from third parties, needed to make the website work and to enhance the user experience. Cookies are also used to detect inexpediencies and to examine your interactions with our website. Read more about how we use cookies and take care of your data here




10 November 2023

The Apple Case: Advocate General Pitruzzella suggests bringing Life to the Commission's EURObn 13 Clawback Claim against Apple

Group 7 Created with Sketch.
Download PDF version

On 9 November 2023, Advocate General Pitruzella has issued his opinion in the historic Apple case (1). In doing so, the Advocate General sides partially with the European Commission’s (“the Commission”) appeal to Court of Justice (“the CJEU”) of the judgment of the General Court (2) whereby the General Court annulled the Commission’s decision to order Ireland to claw back (recover) EURbn 13 for the Apple companies concerned due to certain Irish tax rulings constituting unlawful and incompatible State Aid according to the Commission.

The Advocate General finds that the General Court committed several errors of law in its judgment, for which reason the Advocate General advises the CJEU to set that judgment aside and refer it back to the General Court for the purposes of allowing the General Court to rule on the remaining legal issues.

If the CJEU were to follow the Advocate General when passing its judgment in the appeal case, this could have significant implications for the legal state of play as to when tax rulings may constitute unlawful “State Aid” for the purposes of Articles 107 and 108 TFEU.

By implication and analogy, this could likely also have a similar significant impact on when a tax ruling from a non-EU member state authority could constitute a “Foreign Financial Contribution” or – even – a distortive “Foreign Subsidy” for the purposes of the EU Foreign Subsidies Regulation.

This would imply that undertakings would have to consider and account for such foreign tax rulings in particular when being involved in FSR (3) in-scope M&A transactions and/or EU public procurement procedures.

Thomas Mygind


+45 30 37 96 58

Go to profile

Henrik Ringgaard Diget


+45 30 37 96 81

Go to profile

Josephine Nielsen


+45 30 37 96 08

Go to profile

The Latest

See all insights

1 December 2023

Happy Holidays!

30 November 2023

Dan Moalem: Thought Leader in M&A

18 November 2023

EU proposes Changes to Capital Markets: A Focus on SME Growth and Multiple-Vote Share Structures

10 November 2023

The Apple Case: Advocate General Pitruzzella suggests bringing Life to the Commission's EURObn 13 Clawback Claim against Apple

7 November 2023

The Gram Equipment Case: Private Equity Fund FSN Capital will not be compensated for Losses – Procuritas and former Management of Gram acquitted

27 October 2023

The Danish FSA on the new Process for Submission of Prospectuses, a new ESMA Statement on Requirements for Sustainability Information in Prospectuses, and Disclosure of Management Changes as Inside Information

12 October 2023

Introduction to the EU Foreign Subsidies Regulation

2 October 2023

Morten Krogsgaard joins as Partner and Board Member at Moalem Weitemeyer

14 August 2023

New Partners at Moalem Weitemeyer!

25 July 2023

High-end Car Manufacturer found to have engaged in Greenwashing